Showing posts with label Constipation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Constipation. Show all posts

Wednesday, 10 March 2021

Newborn Presentations

People get worried about newborn babies.  When presented with a baby problem, there are a few basic rules to apply:


Most things that newborns present with are unlikely to have a significant cause.  Some presentations are more concerning that others and while there are no absolutes, it is good to know which things to be more suspicious of.


In many cases, it is possible to significantly change the index of suspicion by knowing the red flags to look out for.


Let's look at a few examples:

Imperfectly shaped head

Since the discovery that putting a baby to sleep on their back dramatically reduces the risk of sudden infant death, there has been a significant rise in the number of babies and infants with asymmetrically shaped heads.


Picture credit: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Plagiocephalie.JPG

The vast majority of babies with this presentation will have plagiocephaly - the result of gravity on a compliant skull.  Plagiocephaly has no apparent risk of harm and requires no intervention.  However, this presentation nicely illustrates the general principles of assessing any presentation in a baby because there is a significant pathology that is rare but significant - craniosynostosis.

So while the head shape is very likely to be nothing to worry about, it is still necessary to look for evidence to support that decision.  The head should be palpated and measured (and plotted), the baby should be given a neurological examination and development should be assessed.

It also follows another rule of newborn presentations: where there is no credible pathology, we should do as much nothing as possible.  We should avoid unnecessary tests and treatments. Remember that the baby is your patient.  Don't do anything to them that does not stand to benefit them directly.

Sticky eyes

While the temptation is to presume that sticky eyes are due to infection, this is rarely the case in newborns.  In most cases the problem is a blocked tear duct.  True eye infections are uncommon and usually quite obvious.  This presentation nicely illustrates the general principles of:

  • Assess the problem - Is the conjunctiva red?  Is there periorbital redness and swelling?
  • Look at the baby - Do they appear well?
  • Decide if there is a significant problem (ophthalmia neonatorum)
  • If not, don't do an unnecessary test (swab) or give an unecessary treatment (antibiotic drops)


Excessive crying

Babies cry.  How much is excessive is hugely subjective and open to interpretation.  Although excessive crying in the absence of pathology has been given a name (colic) this scenario demonstrates the principle that we can't always offer a diagnosis.  Calling the problem colic implies that we know what causes the problem and validates an interventional approach.  There is no treatment for excessive crying in the absence of pathology that has a good evidence base.  Sometimes honesty about uncertainty and futility of intervention is the best policy.


Regurgitation of Feeds

Note the use of the word regurgitation.  People often use the word vomiting or even "projectile vomiting" when neither is what is happening.  Babies often bring back some milk after a feed.  This is generally a passive event, as opposed to vomiting, which is what happens when peristalsis works in reverse or against an obstruction such as pyloric stenosis.

By now, you probably know what I'm going to suggest.

  • Assess the problem - Is regurgitation the only symptom?  Are there red flag features (see above)?  How long has the problem been occurring?  Has it changed much and if so how rapidly?
  • Look at the baby - Do they appear well?  Do they appear well grown?  Plot their growth on a chart.
  • Decide if there is a significant problem (e.g. Pyloric Stenosis) or whether they could be in a feed-cry cycle.
  • If not, don't do an unecessary test or give an unnecessary treatment.  If you give alginates to every regurgitating baby, you'll double your workload as they come back the next week with constipation and without the original symptom having improved.


Not opening bowels for X number of days

Guess what?  Yes: in most cases, the baby who has not passed a stool for the past few days is usually going through something that is normal in the first few weeks of life.

As with all of the low risk newborn presentations, if the baby looks well, examines normally and is growing and developing normally, they are normal.  If something is significantly wrong, it should manifest itself in the history or examination.  In most cases, we should normalise this presentation rather that give something to treat it.

It can be really difficult to do nothing when faced with a baby and a concerned parent.  However, a careful clinical assessment and evaluation are the most important interventions you can offer.  If you have done that and not come up with something serious, explanation and safety netting are the premium service, not the economy class package.


Umbilical presentations

There are rare and significant pathologies that can affect the umbilicus.  Most of these will present at birth or in a way that alerts the clinician to the fact that something is clearly not right,  The more common presentations and the best approach to each are:


Skin presentations

Lots of things can happen to the skin of a baby in the first few days and weeks.  Most presentations are either normal phenomena (peeling skin), dysfunctional but harmless (erythema toxicum) or problematic but mostly uncomplicated (cradle cap).

Picture credit: Skin Deep - a DTFB project

In each case there are simple questions to be answered

  • Peeling skin - Is the baby well?  Is there dermis exposed by the peeling skin (if so then epidermolysis bullosa is a possibile diagnosis)?
  • Erythema toxicum - Is the baby well (erythema toxicum is completely harmless)?
  • Cradle cap (seborrheaic dermatitis capitis) - Is the baby well?  Does the skin have signs of infection?

Peeling skin and erythema toxicum are best left alone.  Cradle cap can be treated with olive oil in most cases.  Occasionally it can become infected.


Jittery Movements

Sleep myoclunus is a normal phenomenon at all ages.  In babies it can cause people to worry thet their child is having a seizure.  This is partly due to the protective reflexes that they are born with such as the moro reflex.

Here we go again with the standard procedure for a newborn presentation:

  • Assess the problem - Are the movemments occuring during or around sleep time?  Is the baby otherwise normal in between episodes?
  • Look at the baby - Do they appear well?  Are they developing normally. Measure and plot head circumference.
  • Decide if there is a significant problem (e.g. Infantile spasms/ West syndrome)
  • If not, don't do an unecessary test or give an unnecessary treatment.  Explain, reassure and give safetynetting advice.

Demedicalising infancy is a good thing to do.  The simple apprach of assess, look and decide will allow you to do that in the majority of cases.  In the rare cases of the discovery of a red flag or atypical presentation, there are always the options of advice or referral.

Edward Snelson
@sailordoctor



Wednesday, 3 October 2018

Don’t say, "Eat healthily." Say. "Eat differently."

It’s highly likely that at some point you have had a conversation with a parent or child about the dietary changes that a child needs to make if they have constipation.  This discussion is fraught with difficulties.  Hands up if you’ve ever heard any of the following:
  • My child eats healthily.
  • Are you saying that I don’t give my child healthy food?
  • I can’t make him eat anything?
  • My child is just a fussy eater.
Sometimes it feels like we are pushing water uphill when we’re trying to explain the importance of diet and fluid intake.  The NICE guidelines for management of childhood constipation (1) de-emphasised the dietary part of resolving the problem.  That is not because diet is unimportant.  It is because dietary changes alone are not seen to be adequate and it is necessary to return normality through the use of macrogol laxatives.  When I ask people why they think constipation is so common in children, they often say that it is because children eat badly.  That may be a factor but the main reason that children become constipated is because they are children.  They have poor visceral awareness, no understanding of what their stools and bowel habit should be, and their behavioural response to the problem worsens the situation.  “It hurts when I poo.  I know, I’ll stop pooing!”

Although macrogol laxatives may be an essential part of the solution, dietary change is still important since management of idiopathic childhood constipation is a game of two halves.

So, why is it so difficult to address the lifestyle changes that are so key to success?  There are several reasons.

The first issue is to do with what is normal.  Parents and children alike only have themselves and those close to them as a reference for what is normal.  It’s hardly an ideal sample, especially when by definition at least one of the people in the reference set has constipation.  Similarly, they will look around themselves when asking themselves what is a normal diet.  As a comparison, ask yourself “What is the normal number of cars for a family of five to have?”  If you look at the globally statistical answer, the answer is zero cars.  Most of us would think about the families in our street or social sphere, not considering the bigger picture.

That’s fine though, because we’re not asking people to feed their child normally, we’re asking them to give their child a healthy diet.  That’s right isn’t it?  It’s technically true, but I think that practically and socially, it is the wrong message.

This is because the second difficulty is that the diet discussion is liable to provoke negative feelings.  As soon as you talk about healthy eating, people become defensive.  They may not vocalise it but that is how they are likely to feel.  There are really only two possibilities.  The first possibility is that they believe that the diet offered to the child is already healthy enough.  The message that the child's diet is not healthy is likely to be perceived as critical, which in turn will sabotage the impact of the message.  The second possibility is that they already know that they are giving an unhealthy diet to the child.  Talking about healthy eating is probably going to ignite feeling of guilt and inadequacy, also getting in the way of the ability to move forward.

Getting the language that we use in this important part of the consultation has the potential to radically alter patient and parent buy-in to what you are recommending.  I would suggest that you try changing just one word.  Instead of talking about eating healthily, talk about eating differently.  I usually explain that no matter what a child’s diet is like, there are always changes that can be made that will help them stay free of constipation.  Let’s think about what changes you could make, since constipation is such a horrible problem that every change that has an effect is great progress.

Here are some things that you could look at with the next constipated child you see:

Achievable changes
  • Cutting out sugary drinks
  • Reducing sweet snacks and starchy snacks (chips and crisps)
Easy wins
  • Change breakfast cereal to something high fibre
  • Ask school to allow a water bottle at all times and a permissive approach to toilet access
Practical tips
  • Don't use sweet and starchy snacks as a reward or treat, even for eating healthy food
  • Don't have the constipation food in the house at all. Instead have fruit out and permanently available
Empowerment
  • Give parents permission to not feed the child. If the child has been offered a healthy meal and they refuse it, don't offer them an alternative. Take the food away and let them know that they can have it back if they change their mind.
  • Tell the family that everyone finds it hard to make changes.  Because constipation is a long term problem, every small change can have a big effect.
Prescribing the laxative is the easy part. Making changes that will have a long term effect is much harder.  It's important that the family understands that we know how challenging it is.  It's also important that they know that we are not asking them to change from unhealthy to healthy.  Diet is not binary. What we do need is positive change.  It's time for the child to eat differently.

Edward Snelson
Definitely different
@sailordoctor

Disclaimer: I have to admit that my kids never got a second crack at their food because I always ate it if they wouldn't.  I'm sure that's fine.  It is fine isn't it?
Reference

  1. Constipation in children and young people: diagnosis and management, [CG99]. NICE, 2017

Thursday, 7 June 2018

The Right Sort of Confidence - (Easter Egg: Acute abdominal pain in children)

I feel pretty confident that my car has the right amount of oil in the engine and air in the tires.  Why?  because that has been the case every time I check these things.  So why bother checking?

Paediatrics is a dangerous speciality because the usual outcome of any child presenting for assessment is that everything is fine.  Fever?  It's probably an uncomplicated viral infection.  Rash?  Virus.  Lump in the neck?  Virus.  You get the idea.

As a result, any one of us can become so used to the benign outcome that we don't expect the dangerous problems or the unusual causes of childhood symptoms.  This is called availability bias.  The last 50 children with this presenting complaint had a virus and got better, so this patient is likely to be the same.

Of course the statement about the likelihood is true, however people don't bring their children to us just for a probability estimate.  We are there to assess whether there is a significant problem that requires intervention.  To get there, we need to know what to look for.

Abdominal pain in children is a good example.  Children often get abdominal pains.  One of the most common presentations is abdominal pain during a febrile illness.  Most likely cause?  Virus.  I suspect that the significant pathology that is most often considered in this situation is appendicitis.  Appendicitis is relatively rare in younger children but paradoxically more difficult to diagnose, so while the chances of a 3 year old having appendicitis is very low, so are the chances that a 3 year old with appendicitis will get this diagnosed easily.

Appendicitis is at least on our minds and so we're probably not going to miss it through failure to look.  There are plenty of causes of abdominal pain that are easily missed for various reasons.  Lower lobe pneumonia, for example, is easily missed because it isn't in the abdomen.  Testicular torsion is easily missed if it isn't looked for.  You'd think that if a child or young person had a problem with their genitalia they might mention that.  They often don't.  If you don't look for torsion, you won't find it.

Here's a brief overview of some of the easily missed causes of abdominal pain in children:
Here is a more extensive list of possible causes of abdominal pain in children. (1)

Going through these, starting at one o'clock:

Mesenteric Adenitis - Yes, children with viral upper respiratory tract infection can get acute abdominal pains and can even have localised abdominal tenderness.  Children with more significant causes of pain can also have URTI, so if there are red flag signs or symptoms you should still take these seriously.
Non-IgE food allergy - This can cause acute abdominal pain but paradoxically is a diagnosis best not made acutely.  History, a food diary and follow-up are the way forward when food allergy becomes a possibility.
Gastroenteritis - When vomiting precedes abdominal pain then this makes gastroenteritis more likely.  Similarly, diarrhoea is a strong indicator of viral enteritis.  However, there is no such thing as always, so careful abdominal examination is key and signs that suggest a surgical cause should still lead to referral.
Gynaecological - The main thing to say about this is that it is a common pitfall to forget to even consider this possibility in children.  How often do you think ectopic pregnancy is considered in the differential of a 13 year old with acute abdominal pain?  It should always be remembered as a possiblity.  Do a pregnancy test.
Constipation - This is possibly the most common cause of afebrile acute abdominal pain in children.  There are two main pitfalls.  The first is to miss the diagnosis because the child or parent doesn't think the child is constipated.  The second is to think that because the presentation is acute, the problem just needs a brief period of treatment.  If they are constipated enough to present with acute pain, the problem is chronic and should be treated as such as per NICE guidelines.
Urinary Tract Infection - Abdominal pain +/- vomiting without diarrhoea is a common way for children to present with UTI.  There is no absolute rule on when and when not to test a urine but it is fair to say that significant diarrhoea usually precludes it for a couple of reasons.  In all other cases of acute abdominal pain, it is usually a good idea even if interpreting the result is not completely straightforward.
Colic - Truly a diagnosis of exclusion, but this can be a good history and examination. What to do with colic is covered here.
Appendicitis - Uncommon but not so rare that you won't see a case every now and then. Picking them out from the crowd can be difficult.  Good simple analgesia and reassessment after an hour is often a helpful discriminator for the grey cases if you can do that.
Testicular torsion - Inguinal and genital examination is part of the examination of a male presenting with abdominal pain.  Do it, even if the last 100 times were normal.
Intussusception - Rare but deadly.  Episodes of pallor and signs of being significantly unwell are reasons to suspect intussusception.  Bloody and mucousy (recurrent jelly-like) stools make it easier to diagnose but may be a late sign.
Diabetic Ketoacidosis - It is very easy to see how first presentations are initially diagnosed as viral illnesses.  If you've got a child who's a bit more lethargic or subdued than your typical gastroenteritis case, or if there is a report of polyuria, test a glucose.

In most cases, significant causes will be excluded by a thorough history and examination.  Often a urine test is a good idea and sometimes a second opinion will be necessary.  Abdominal X-ray is almost never useful in making a decision about referral.

Paradoxically,  the wrong sort of confidence comes from repeated experience of nothing bad happening.  The right sort of confidence comes from knowing that bad things will happen and knowing that we're ready for that eventuality.  This often happens once you've experienced the sharp end of an unexpected diagnosis.  If that has happened, congratulations!  You're now an expert.

Edward Snelson
Experienced if not Expert
@sailordoctor

Disclaimer - Experience doesn't always lead to expertise but it's a fairly important element. Bad experience is a good wad to develop great expertise but only if you have all the right elements in place to ensure that you learn without becoming a second victim.  I would like to see more work in that area, especially at the Primary/ Secondary Care interface.

Reference

  1. The Essential Clinical Handbook of Common Paediatric Cases, Edward Snelson

Monday, 6 November 2017

A Paediatric Guide to Anatomy (Things You Should Know about Constipation and Urinary Tract Infection in Children)

Last week, Norfolk and Norwich University Hospitals announced the opening of the UK's first Senior Emergency Department.  A Senior Emergency Department is much like a Paediatric Emergency Department, except that this one will meet the needs of patients over the age of 80, instead of those under the age of 16.  The concept is the same - there is a specific patient group with a different set of needs and who present in different ways to the rest of the adult population.

Children have been able to access paediatric emergency departments for a long time now.  Children benefit from a child-friendly waiting area, an assessment that recognises the way that children are different from adults and treatment by clinicians who are specifically trained in child health.  Perhaps that makes it all sound very exclusive and mysterious.  What are these differences of which you speak?  Well, none of them are a great secret, but as is often the case, having something explained often helps it to be understood better, even if you already knew it.

So, here's something that you probably already knew, but was a fact that you hadn't necessarily known what to do with: Children have a considerable lack of body awareness. 

A child's approach to anatomy and physiology is fairly simple:  I eat, I wee and I poo.  I pick things up if I want them.  If I want to do any of those things in a different location then I move.  If the world isn't the way I want it to be, I make noises.

One of my top tips when teaching paediatric clinical examination is that children don't have a chest before they go to school.  To them, the space between mouth and stomach is presumably some sort of giant food processing area.  Functions like breathing and circulation only truly become a reality when a child is much older.  For that reason I never tell a young child that I am going to listen to their chest.  It only confuses them if you say that.  I tell them I am going to listen to their tummy and tell them what I can hear.  Usually, the answer is sausages.

Besides helping me to know what to say to children, my knowledge of their lack of body awareness is crucial when it comes to understanding visceral presentations in children.  The important thing to understand is that children seem mostly unable to recognise the significance of visceral symptoms.  In other words, the feelings in their bowel and bladder either make no sense to them, or they are unable to articulate these feelings.  For whatever reason, young children have a tendency to leave bowel and bladder symptoms unreported, and so the presentation of problems such as urinary tract infection (UTI) and constipation are always delayed.

Take this case history example:
A two year old child presents with a 12 hour history of dysuria and frequency of urine.  They have no fever or abdominal pain.

Well, that's all very well, but that's just not how it goes.  Let's try something more realistic:
A two year old presents with a three day history of fever.  The child first presented two days ago and was diagnosed as having viral gastroenteritis.  The child is vomiting intermittently.  There is no blood or bile in the vomit.  The child does not have diarrhoea.
Today the parents have noticed that their child is more unsettled and they think that the child has abdominal pain, although the child has not specifically said that their tummy hurts.

Why is it important to recognise this peculiarity of children?

The first reason is that we need to be aware that UTI is a diagnosis that we have to actively  seek in children.  UTI in younger children does not have specific (urinary) symptoms.  Instead, all of the features are those also found in the more common viral infections such as gastroenteritis or URTI.

This does not mean that all unwell children should have a urine tested.  Routine testing would be great if it were painless for the family and the clinician.  Neither of these things are true.  Getting an uncontaminated sample (a 'clean catch') is hard work much of the time.  Interpreting the results and making sense of conflicting information is a challenge once a sample is obtained.  For that reason I would not routinely ask for a urine sample in a child who has an obvious otitis media for example.

The things that make UTI more likely in children include:

  • previous UTI
  • abdominal pain/ tenderness
  • vomiting without diarrhoea
  • a report of odd smelling urine
  • absence of signs or symptoms of URTI
  • new urinary symptoms (enuresis, dysuria)

The second reason is that we need to be aware that both UTI and constipation are likely to be well established by the time they are diagnosed.   This means that in children, we have to take each of these diagnoses a little more seriously.

Although most children with UTI are well at presentation, they probably have an infection that is a little more than what would be considered cystitis.  They may not have a proper pyelonephritis yet, but they are likely to have a more established infection than a young adult would have.  It is for this reason that we need to make sure that we do pick up a diagnosis of UTI as early as possible.  Every day left untreated increases the risk of renal scarring.

With constipation, the significance of the way it presents is more to do with the length of treatment needed to resolve the problem than the urgency to start treatment (as with UTI in children).  By the time that the child and parent are aware of the problem, constipation is usually very well established.  The child's bowel has been full of stool for weeks or months.  The bowel is stretched, weak and insensitive.  Prune juice and porridge are simply not going to do the job of resolving the constipation by the time that a child gets as far as their first medical assessment.

At this point, a short course of treatment for constipation simply will not suffice to truly resolve the problem.  Macrogol laxatives (the treatment recommended by the UK's NICE guideline) will do a great job, in almost every case, of clearing out the bowel.  This is not the same as treating the underlying condition.  We need to continue treatment until the bowel has a chance to do its thing again.


The effective treatment of idiopathic constipation in children requires two things.  Firstly, it requires adequate doses the right laxative (I avoid lactulose) for as long as it takes to allow the return of strength, shape and sensation to the bowel.  The consensus on this is that this will take about six months of maintenance therapy to achieve.

The second thing needed is some sort of modification to lifestyle that will help to avoid the return to constipation once treatment is stopped.  Changing diet, fluid intake and toileting habits may make all the difference, once the treatment has given the child their normal bowel back.

So I would suggest that we never think in terms of 'just a UTI' or 'a little bit of constipation' in children.  The delay in presentation, coupled with the extra time it may take us to actually get to the diagnosis means that neither of these terms apply.

I suspect that this could all be applied to the elderly with a little modification, but I'm not about to start GPseniorsTips.blogspot.com.  I'll just leave that thought with my innovative colleagues at the Norfolk and Norwich University Hospitals.

Edward Snelson
Part-time Vicerologist
@sailordoctor

Disclaimer - While I know deep down that it would be a terrible idea, part of me wants to combine a Paediatric Emergency Department with a Senior Emergency Department.  I can imagine how the two patient groups would be quite good for each other.  And that folks, is why I should never be allowed to have ideas.






Tuesday, 28 March 2017

The Random Goldfish - When confirmation bias met affective bias


In the previous post, I explored how confirmation bias can lead us to believe that something is causing a problem when really it isn't.  Although sometimes unexpected, this kind of news is not unwelcome.  Finding out that fever doesn't really cause febrile convulsions is a surprise to many, but usually a good one.  Telling people that their treatments don't work is much less popular.

Anyone who has been a clinician for a reasonable amount of time knows what it feels like to share good and bad news with someone.  When I am teaching about paediatrics in primary care, it sometimes feels like I am saying that very few treatments actually work.  This feels having something taken away form us.  The real headline is that children make themselves better in the vast majority of clinical scenarios.  It is our job as clinicians to do as much nothing as possible while looking for opportunities to give effective treatments.

One question that I am often asked is, "If these treatments don't work, why do people use them?" Good question.  I tend to assume that my sample cohort of co-workers is representative of clinicians and I work with good, conscientious people who want to give children the best treatment possible. Since I don't believe that clinicians are generally unintelligent, malicious or lazy, I will take a risk and say that there must be powerful forces at work if any of us are giving ineffective medicines to children.  The problem that leads us all to use ineffective treatments is our very desire to make children better and parents happy.

If you want something really badly and do something in an attempt to make it come about, when the thing happens, we are likely to believe that this was cause and effect.  This approach would work in a fixed environment,  For example, consider a person trying to solve a puzzle (like a Rubik's Cube).  The puzzle isn't going to solve itself, so if the person tries many different strategies and then something works, they have solved the puzzle.  This assumes that the puzzle has not been solved by chance, which in this case is extremely unlikely.

Now consider someone with a different problem.  He wants a picture of his goldfish next to the castle in the goldfish bowl.  He tries shining a light to get the goldfish to move into position.  He tries tapping the glass, placing some food and tries making waves in the tank.  Whatever he does just before the goldfish moves into position must have done the trick right?  Wrong.

Well, much of paediatrics is like that.  Childhood symptoms often fluctuate or resolve.  We want our treatments to work.  We want to make children better and parents to be happy.  These factors are the perfect ingredients for us to wrongly believe that what we did worked.  Sometimes though, the goldfish just moves.  Because it's a goldfish.

Enough about goldfish. Let's use a really common example of how confirmation bias leads us and our patients to believe in an effect that is not real.

If I tell someone that antibiotics will cure a child's throat infection within a week, you can imagine how that sounds plausible.  Then, the initial belief in my statement will be reinforced when the child does indeed get better.  The true believer does not consider that the alternative is just as plausible - that all (uncomplicated) throat infections get better with time.  You know that guy who still has the viral sore throat he caught when he was two years old?  No?  Neither do I.

Paediatrics is a branch of medicine where most illnesses will resolve with time and many symptoms that could be attributed to a treatable cause.  But we and the parents both want the problem to be treatable.  The problem is, you're too nice.  You want to help and you want everyone to leave happy. This is called affective bias (the thing that reinforces confirmation bias). The end result is that we can easily believe that we are treating a problem, when in fact it gets better on its own.


Now, bias gets a bad name in medicine, but I would like to defend bias.  Clinicians could never learn or make decisions without bias.  We would be permanently uncertain and unable to choose. Without confirmation bias, we would never notice a pattern.  Without affective bias we would never take the parents seriously or care about the child.

Bias is good.  There, I've said it.

Bias is your friend, but friends can be fickle.  The thing about friends is that despite their faults, they're still your friends.  It is good to know what to expect from them.  That way, you don't feel surprised when they do the thing that they always do.  In the case of bias, your friend wants to mislead you and get you do do things you shouldn't do.

So, what are the best examples of the confirmation bias of presumed effect in paediatrics?  I've already mentioned antibiotics for upper respiratory tract infection.  There are many more, but lets just look at one in detail as an example:

Confirmation bias (presumed effect) - 
Example number 2: Treatments for gastro-oesophageal reflux disease in infants
If there was ever a paediatric condition that fitted the brief for this subject, it is feeding problems in babies.  The symptoms that babies present with are so often simply withing normal limits for infancy.   Did you know that straining is a thing that 1 in 6 babies do and that it is called dyschezia, not constipation?  If you add regurgitation of milk (aka 'reflux'), colic and other common gastrointestinal complaints, most babies have some sort of symptom that we could treat if we chose to during the first few months of life.  With a few exceptions, these are normal for being a baby, and will resolve in time.

The cardinal sign of a self resolving problem is that there are treatments available without good evidence of efficacy.  (Cough medicines for children are a good example of this.)  By way of contrast, there are very few treatment strategies for the management of pneumonia.  I'm guessing that you probably use antibiotics.

The evidence for the available treatments for reflux disease is not good.  In many cases the evidence is that they have little effect.  Rather than posting several dozen references, I am simply going to signpost you to the NICE guideline for Gastro-oesophageal reflux disease in children and young people. (1)  In the full document there is an extensive literature review which makes for interesting reading.  The bottom line is that the evidence is usually lacking.  The evidence that we do have form research points toward little or no effect for alginates, H2 agonists and PPIs.  By their own admission, much of the advice in the guideline depends on the experience of the experts involved in the guideline writing process.

Of course the problem is that there are infants with genuine pathology.  These children often begin their visits to healthcare professionals with non-specific presentations which easily fit the bill for what is 'normal for infancy'.  If we are honest with ourselves, the niggling doubt that the child might have a significant problem is one of the factors that pushes us in the direction of pulling out our prescription pads.  After all, it won't look as bad when the child turns out to have a problem later if we were busy trying treatments instead of reassuring the parent that these symptoms are usually part of normal infancy.

Avoiding unnecessary treatments is gold standard care.  Alginates are the most frequently used medications for reflux symptoms but in my experience this treatment runs a high risk of causing constipation.  This is far from ideal if you are trying to make life easier for baby and parent alike.   Motility drugs have repeatedly been associated with dangerous cardiac side effects and PPIs have been shown to increase the risk of respiratory tract infection. (2)  The take home message from this is that, although medication is an option, we need to be sure that a treatment is really likely to be better than watchful waiting.

The NICE guidelines focus on consideration of how the infant is affected - severe distress or red flags (faltering growth, feed refusal etc.).  It is also important to consider other possible diagnoses such as UTI.

I said that there were quite a few problems that have a similar story.  Going through all of them in detail would take a long time, but here is a list of some of the treatments that lend themselves to this combined bias effect:
The evidence for all of these treatments in children is that they work rarely (antibiotics for URTI, inhalers for cough alone, suspected CMPA based on colic alone) or never (cough syrups, simethicone or lactase for colic in babies).  All of these clinical scenarios share a common theme- the likelihood that the symptom will resolve in time.

So lets come back to bias.  Confirmation bias will cause us to believe that a treatment is effective while affective bias will make us want to give something even when there is little or no benefit. "But earlier, you said that bias is good.  You said that bias is my friend!" you might well say.  I stand by that.  As long as you know how you expect your friends to behave, any misbehavior can be managed and they can still be your friends.

For confirmation bias, we need to have good evidence to justify treatment that is used for symptoms when the natural course is resolution with time.  For example, I don't need evidence to back up my belief that morphine works for pain when a child has a broken leg.  If the child feels less pain afterwards, it has nothing to do with a goldfish effect.  Conversely, I should want evidence that a treatment is effective for any of the symptoms listed above.

For affective bias, we need to harness our desire to be nice to parents and children.  That means not wasting their time with ineffective treatments or worse still causing new problems. Sometimes, doing nothing is the nicest thing that you can do.  Managing to treat where appropriate and avoid unnecessary treatment is the holy grail of paediatrics.  Ultimately, the child is the patient and we need to only give them medication that is more likely to help than harm.  At least, that's what we should be trying to do despite our biases.

Edward Snelson
Amateur Medical Errorist
@sailordoctor

Disclaimer - I am too biased to be taken seriously, even by myself.



References
  1. NG1 - Guideline for Gastro-oesophageal reflux disease in children and young people, NICE
  2. Orenstein et al., Multicenter, double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled trial assessing the efficacy and safety of proton pump inhibitor lansoprazole in infants with symptoms of gastroesophageal reflux disease, J Pediatr. 2009 Apr;154(4):514-520


Thursday, 9 February 2017

Dates for your diary – Constipation in Children

If (like me) you are still sorting out your 2017 diary, I have some important dates for you to add.  They all relate to that child who you are about to see with constipation.

Constipation is very common in children over the age of one year old, being prevalent in around 20% of children.  It is responsible for many presentations to GPs, Emergency Departments and other unscheduled care providers.  Sometimes the family knows that constipation is the problem but often they are perplexed by symptoms that they do not necessarily associate with constipation.

By far the most common perplexing symptom of constipation is abdominal pain.  This pain can be acute, chronic or both.  It can be severe or mild enough that the child does not articulate their discomfort to the parents.

So, back to the diary: this child who is presenting with what turns out to have constipation has a timeline.  Assuming that they presenting for the first time, now in February 2017, these are the relevant dates:

August 2016

This is the time that the child began to become constipated.  It is often the case that it seems that the problem has been there for a much shorter period.  When the child eventually comes to see you, the parents may have been aware of the abdominal pain for a few days or hours, but it takes a long time to become constipated to the point that symptoms occur.  Think of it like a massive ship.  It takes a long time for one of these to come to a full stop.  Likewise, it takes months for bowels to reach the point that they are loaded and unable to function, which is the point at which they will present to you.

February 2017

The parents will present now because they recognise a problem.  This maybe abdominal pain or perhaps they have seen blood on the toilet paper.  Often, there will be a reluctance to accept that constipation is the cause of these things.  This is for a variety of reasons.


Parents are unlikely to know exactly what a child's bowel habit is.  Asking if the child opens their bowels and if this is normal is unlikely to unmask constipation as the villain here.  Instead it is important to ask specific questions.

  • Does the child strain to pass stool?
  • Is it painful for the child to open their bowels?
  • Is there ever blood on the stools or toilet paper?
  • What do the stools look like?


If they identify type 1, 2 or 3 stool from the Bristol chart, this indicates constipation.  If the child is passing only liquid stools, this may be overflow due to severe constipation.

If the problem is most likely constipation, it is also very probable that it is idiopathic constipation.  In the absence of red flags, it is usually appropriate to treat without any need for investigation.


The best treatment is macrogol laxatives (1) in increasing doses to achieve easy passage of formed stools.  It may be necessary to see this child on a few occasions to get the dose of laxative perfect.  The aim is to have the child passing soft, well formed stools easily.


There is a lot to explain in the first consultation.  Parents and children often disbelieve that constipation may be causing the child's symptoms.  I find that pictures help.


Pictures taken from The Essential Handbook of Common Paediatric Cases and used with permission from BPP learning media. (2)


March 2017

By now the symptoms of idiopathic constipation should be improving or possibly gone.  This is an important visit because there are two essential outcomes for this child.

1 - Do not stop the macrogol laxatives.  It takes a long time to become so constipated that you will go to see a doctor.  By the time children present, they have a stretched, weak and numb bowel.  If you stop their laxative now it is too soon.  NICE recommends 4-6 months of treatment in order to restore the shape, strength and sensation to the colon before the child is weaned off medication.

2 - Reinforce the message about the importance of diet and toileting.  Of course you covered this when you first started the medication, but for ten different reasons, it is unlikely that this message has been fully heard and understood.


August 2017

This may seem like a long time away, but this is when it might be time to reduce and stop the laxatives.  If the child has been taking their macrogol for about six months, then the shape, strength and sensation should have returned.  This gives them the best possible chance of being constipation free.  Diet and lifestyle are just as important at this stage as when they were first diagnosed.  Treating and preventing constipation is a lot of hard work  but the results are worth it.

Edward Snelson
Specialist Spitilomancer
@sailordoctor

Please note that babies who struggle to pass stool are often  experiencing a normal physiological phenomenon called dyschasia.

References
  1. Constipation in children and young people: diagnosis and management, NICE CG99
  2. The Essential Clinical Handbook for Common Paediatric Cases: A Practical Guide to Assessing Children in General Practice, the Paediatric Assessment Unit and the Emergency Department, BPP Learning Media







Wednesday, 10 June 2015

I learned a new word today... (Easter eggs - 'Constipation' in babies and things you might not know about lactulose)

Why I have stopped using lactulose to treat babies


This month’s Archive of Disease in Childhood published an interesting paper on defecation patterns in infants. (1)  The most interesting thing for me was that I learned a new word: dyschezia.  The definition of dyschezia is difficulty with defaecation.  While it might seem like a superfluous word to those of us who use terms like constipation and painful, in the context of this article it has an important place in medical terminology because it makes a valuable distinction.

It has long bothered me that babies are referred to as being constipated.  Certainly they might go for days without passing stools and when they finally do they often do their best tomato impression.  While constipation is not the wrong word for what babies go through, it creates the impression that there is significant overlap with the constipation that is so common among older children and this is just not the case.

So what is happening to babies?  The truth is that we just don’t know.   Babies seem to be born with a tendency for their gastrointestinal tract to cause all sorts of alarming symptoms.  We use diagnoses such as colic and posseting in an attempt to give labels to things that seem to be normal phenomena in babies.  These problems are self-limiting however and are probably a feature of a GI tract that is 'learning' how to function effectively.  The trouble with each of these is that they have significant counterparts made up of a list of less common but very significant medical problems. 

Every baby who presents with symptoms that could be due to abdominal pathology should be carefully assessed to exclude such problems including urinary tract infection and surgical problems.  The full list of possibilities is much longer of course but the major clues that the baby does not have these is that they should be alert but settled, thriving and hydrated, afebrile and have no alarming signs or symptoms.
So if we are left with a baby which is not opening its bowels, straining at stool and intermittently getting upset, what do we do?  One thing that I am quite convinced of is that lactulose is not the best medicine for babies no matter what the problem. 

This brings me back my new word: dyschezia.  When babies fail to pass stools, or they strain and show signs of discomfort, they don’t have constipation in the way that a six year old has constipation.  The baby has a gut that is doing something but ineffectively while the six year olds guts are just not doing the thing at all.  “That’s fine,” you may say. “Lactulose is a stool softener so it will help the baby pass stool in this way.”  That’s what I used to believe too until a helpful pharmacist told me about how lactulose really works.  Lactulose does have an osmotic effect but it is also an irritant because when metabolised by the gut bacteria the result is chemicals such as acetic acid, lactic acid and formic acid.



So if a baby is failing to open its bowels because it’s a baby then I prefer not to use lactulose.  If I think that the problem is that the baby has guts that are trying, then driving them harder seems unfair.  I like to think about what we advise parents about how sensitive baby skin is.  How much more sensitive will their gut lining be?

What does work?    If anything is going to work, a glycerine suppository could be tried and in my experience is often successful.  More often the answer is time.  Essentially dyschezia is a common and transient phenomenon which will eventually resolve and is not a risk factor for constipation later in childhood. (1)  As is often the way in paediatrics, time spent looking for the correct diagnosis and explaining things properly to the parents is time well spent.



Finally, I think that dychezia is a terrible word, right up there with erythema toxicum on the list of things that I will never say to parents that their child has.  Can anyone out there suggest a better one?

Edward Snelson
Junior gunner, Crimson Permanent Assurance

References:
(1) Defecation patterns in infants: a prospective cohort study (Kramer et Al, Arch Dis Child, doi:10.1136/archdischild-2014-307448)


Disclaimer:  I don’t know what babies are thinking either.




Sunday, 17 May 2015

Non-specific or non-diagnosis? Non-specific abdominal pain (Easter Egg: Constipation in Children)

Non-specific abdominal pain - why I haven't made that diagnosis for quite some time



I think that I have now heard more than a dozen definitions of constipation and diarrhoea, starting from a lecture that I recall well from when I was at medical school.  The lecturer gave scientific definitions based on volumes and frequency of stool passed in a 24 hr period that led me to believe that I would be able to conclusively diagnose or rule out constipation if only I took a thorough history and a large set of scales with me.


I also recall first hearing about non-specific abdominal pain in children.  It seemed mysterious and yet strangely credible.  It was, I was told, a diagnosis of exclusion.  Presumably the diagnosis of constipation in these children was being excluded by the use of CCTV installed in the child’s toilet and a rigorous measuring of the amount and consistency of everything brown before it was flushed.


I now know the reality, which is that the diagnosis of constipation in children is usually a guess, albeit it a good guess and hopefully an educated one.  Every week I see at least one child of the many who present to our Emergency Department with what turns out to be constipation.  In most cases the most significant symptoms have been present for many days and if one enquires, the clues have been there for months or years.  These children have usually had various people consider what the cause is - parents, GPs and Emergency Physicians.  Often the parents have been given no diagnosis; on other occasions non-specific abdominal pain might have been given as the cause. In reality, the well child with unexplained abdominal pain (once an acute abdomen and a urinary tract infection have been ruled out) almost always turns out to have constipation.


So my question is, how was constipation excluded in the diagnosis of exclusion that is non-specific abdominal pain?  I suspect that there are two things getting in the way.  The first is that it is almost impossible to get a good history about the bowel habit of a child.   They think that whatever they do is normal and their parents are unlikely to know what they are passing and how often.  The second factor is time.  I know that there is limited time to assess a child in Primary Care and let’s be honest, there are other more pressing diagnoses to exclude if a child presents with abdominal pain.  Ruling out a surgical abdomen and a urinary tract infection is always going to be the priority and I can’t do that in less than 10 minutes either.


I feel that there are opportunities being missed though and childhood constipation is one of the best diagnoses to make in primary care for several reasons.
  1. It is a difficult diagnosis to make.  All clinicians want to be the first on the scene at a difficult diagnosis and this is your chance.
  2. It requires good explanation and consultation skills in order to engage the family with understanding what is happening and what to do about it.  No further comment needed.
  3. This is a condition that can be managed entirely in primary care without interference from anyone else.
  4. It is a really satisfying condition to treat.  So much childhood illness either gets better on its own, responds poorly to treatment or is untreatable that we should be genuinely excited when we find a condition that probably won’t get better until we diagnose it and do something about it.
  5. The effect on quality of life for the child and family is enormous.

I would suggest that non-specific abdominal pain is so often code for undiagnosed constipation that we only use it when constipation has been thoroughly ruled out.  I have been working to this for many years now and I find that once challenged, the evidence for constipation almost always comes out just in the history of children with abdominal pains.  If not in the history then often the examination might reveal hard stools or just a fullness in the left lower quadrant.  A normal examination does not exclude constipation.  Finally, if the pains have been consistent for a while and a macrogol laxative (1) has not yet been tried then this is the controversial bit:  I would not make a diagnosis of non-specific abdominal pain without first attempting to treat as constipation and reviewing early to assess the result.


Does non-specific abdominal pain exist?  I’m told it does but I haven’t yet seen a case myself.


Edward Snelson
Consultant in Paediatric Emergency Medicine
@sailordoctor


1)    Constipation in children and young people: Diagnosis and management of idiopathic childhood constipation in primary and secondary care https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/cg99

Note: This material is created by the author for the sole use of qualified clinicians.  It is meant as a viewpoint and not intended to replace any applicable guidelines.  Any change in practice is solely the responsibility of the clinician.

Conflict of Interest: Loads

Easter egg: Constipation in Children - key recommendations

  • Suspect constipation whenever a child presents with abdominal pain
  • UTI is a common co-existing problem and should be ruled out concurrently. The finding of a urine infection increases the index of suspicion for constipation rather than ruling it out.
  • Do not treat with lifestyle measures only (1)
  • Treat all presentations of constipation with a macrogol laxative (either clear out or maintenance as indicated) (1)
  • Continue this treatment for at least several week. It is likely that several months will be needed to prevent recurrence. (1)